Enterprise AI Analysis
No One Left Behind: How to Exploit the Incomplete and Skewed Multi-Label Data for Conversion Rate Prediction
Authors: Qinglin Jia, Zhaocheng Du, Chuhan Wu, Huifeng Guo, Ruiming Tang, Shuting Shi, Muyu Zhang
Abstract: In most real-world online advertising systems, advertisers typically have diverse customer acquisition goals. A common solution is to use multi-task learning (MTL) to train a unified model on post-click data to estimate the conversion rate (CVR) for these diverse targets. In practice, CVR prediction often encounters missing conversion data as many advertisers submit only a subset of user conversion actions due to privacy or other constraints, making the labels of multi-task data incomplete. If the model is trained on all available samples where advertisers submit user conversion actions, it may struggle when deployed to serve a subset of advertisers targeting specific conversion actions, as the training and deployment data distributions are mismatched. While considerable MTL efforts have been made, a long-standing challenge is how to effectively train a unified model with the incomplete and skewed multi-label data. In this paper, we propose a fine-grained Knowledge transfer framework for Asymmetric Multi-Label data (KAML). We introduce an attribution-driven masking strategy (ADM) to better utilize data with asymmetric multi-label data in training. However, the more relaxed masking in ADM is a double-edged sword: it provides additional training signals but also introduces noise due to skewed data. To address this, we propose a hierarchical knowledge extrac-tion mechanism (HKE) to model the sample discrepancy within the targe task tower. Finally, to maximize the utility of unlabeled sam-ples, we incorporate ranking loss strategy to further enhance our model. The effectiveness of KAML has been demonstrated through comprehensive evaluations on offline industry datasets and online A/B tests, which show significant performance improvements over existing MTL baselines.
Executive Impact Summary
The KAML framework drives significant improvements in online advertising performance, validated by real-world A/B tests and comprehensive offline evaluations.
Deep Analysis & Enterprise Applications
Select a topic to dive deeper, then explore the specific findings from the research, rebuilt as interactive, enterprise-focused modules.
At its core, KAML introduces a fine-grained Knowledge transfer framework for Asymmetric Multi-Label data (KAML). This framework addresses the inherent challenges of incomplete and skewed multi-label data commonly found in online advertising CVR prediction. Unlike traditional MTL methods, KAML is designed to fully leverage all available data, ensuring no information is left unused, which is critical given the scarcity of positive samples in CVR prediction.
KAML’s methodology is structured around three key innovations: 1. Attribution-Driven Masking Strategy (ADM): This strategy generates masks for each post-click sample based on historical advertiser data, distinguishing between negative and unlabeled samples. It provides additional training signals but is carefully balanced to mitigate noise from skewed data. 2. Hierarchical Knowledge Extraction (HKE): To address distribution discrepancies, HKE models sample discrepancies within target task towers, using different parameters for samples from targeting vs. other advertisers. 3. Ranking-based Label Utilization (RLU): This strategy combines BCE loss with ranking loss to mine information from unlabeled samples, enhancing both ranking and classification performance.
KAML has been extensively validated through comprehensive evaluations on offline industry datasets, public datasets, and online A/B tests. Key results include: A 12.11% increase in Revenue Per Mille (RPM) and a 0.92% improvement in Conversion Rate (CVR) in online A/B tests, demonstrating significant real-world effectiveness. Offline experiments show KAML outperforms all baselines in individual tasks and overall performance, substantiating the effectiveness of its three modules: ADM, HKE, and RLU.
Our KAML framework delivered a substantial 12.11% increase in Revenue Per Mille (RPM) during online A/B tests, underscoring its real-world impact on advertising revenue. This metric directly reflects improved ad delivery and monetization efficiency, demonstrating KAML's capability to drive superior business outcomes.
Enterprise Process Flow
The KAML framework integrates three interdependent components designed to address the challenges of incomplete and skewed multi-label data. Each step builds upon the previous one, creating a robust system for CVR prediction.
| Feature | KAML | Best Baseline (TAML) |
|---|---|---|
| Overall AUC | 0.9133 | 0.9116 |
| Overall LogLoss | 0.2500 | 0.2459 |
| Handles Incomplete Labels | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
| Addresses Skewed Data | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
| Leverages Unlabeled Samples | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
KAML significantly outperforms existing Multi-Task Learning (MTL) baselines, particularly TAML, across critical performance metrics. Our framework's innovative masking and knowledge extraction mechanisms specifically tackle the challenges of incomplete and skewed multi-label data, providing a distinct advantage in real-world CVR prediction scenarios.
Real-World A/B Test: KAML's Impact on Live Ad Platform
Deployed on a mainstream online advertising platform, KAML underwent an 8-day online A/B test. The results conclusively demonstrated its superiority in a live environment. The system showed remarkable stability and consistent improvements across key performance indicators.
- Online RPM Increase: 12.11%
- Online CVR Improvement: 0.92%
- Targeted Campaigns Served: Hundreds of Millions
- Data Utilization: Maximized for all submitted data
The online A/B test provided irrefutable evidence of KAML's effectiveness. With 12.11% increase in RPM and 0.92% improvement in CVR, KAML not only enhanced ad platform efficiency but also significantly boosted advertiser ROI. This real-world validation confirms KAML's robust performance and its readiness for large-scale enterprise deployment.
Calculate Your Potential ROI with AI
Estimate the time and cost savings your enterprise could achieve by integrating advanced AI solutions like KAML.
Our Proven Implementation Roadmap
A structured approach to integrating KAML and other advanced AI solutions into your enterprise workflow.
Phase 01: Discovery & Strategy
In-depth analysis of your current systems, data infrastructure, and business objectives. We collaborate to define clear KPIs and a tailored AI strategy.
Phase 02: Data Integration & Modeling
Secure integration of your multi-label data, implementation of KAML's ADM and HKE mechanisms, and custom model training and validation.
Phase 03: Deployment & A/B Testing
Staged deployment of the KAML model, rigorous A/B testing to measure real-world impact, and continuous performance monitoring.
Phase 04: Optimization & Scaling
Ongoing model refinement, performance optimization based on live data, and strategic scaling across additional business units or campaigns.
Ready to Transform Your Ad Performance?
Unlock the full potential of your incomplete and skewed multi-label data with KAML. Our experts are ready to guide you.