Enterprise AI Analysis: The Telltale Signs of AI-Generated Content
An in-depth look at the study "ChatGPT for President!" by Garassino, Brocca, & Masia, and what it means for your company's communication strategy.
Executive Summary: Why Your Business Can't Afford "Vanilla" AI
A groundbreaking linguistic study, "ChatGPT for President! Presupposed content in politicians versus GPT-generated texts," provides critical insights for any enterprise leveraging AI. The research reveals that while Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT can mimic human communication, they do so with a distinct, predictable, and often less effective "tell."
The study found that AI-generated political speeches, compared to those by real politicians, overuse certain persuasive techniques while strictly avoiding others. Specifically, AI leans on safe, non-confrontational language (Stance-Taking) and avoids direct or implied criticism. This "guardrailed" nature results in content that feels subtly inauthentic and lacks the strategic nuance of expert human communication. For businesses, this means off-the-shelf AI can dilute your brand voice, neutralize competitive messaging, and fail to build genuine connection. The key takeaway is clear: to achieve strategic communication goals, enterprises need custom-tuned AI that transcends these generic limitations.
Deconstructing the Research: The Linguistics of Persuasion
To understand the enterprise implications, we first need to grasp the core linguistic concepts the paper explores. The researchers analyzed how politicians and AI use Potentially Manipulative Presuppositions (PMPs)a subtle way of embedding information into a sentence as if it's already common knowledge.
Key Concept 1: Presupposition Triggers
These are the specific words or phrases that create the presupposition. The study focused on two main types, which we can translate into business contexts:
- Change-of-State Verbs (CSV): Words that imply a transition. Ex: "Our new software will stop manual data entry errors." (Presupposes errors are currently happening). The study found AI heavily overuses these.
- Definite Descriptions (DEF): Noun phrases starting with "the" or a possessive that imply existence and uniqueness. Ex: "Our award-winning customer service team..." (Presupposes the team exists and has won awards). The study found politicians use these more strategically than AI.
Key Concept 2: Discourse Functions
This is the *purpose* of the presupposition. What is the speaker trying to achieve? The analysis identified four key functions:
- Stance-Taking (STK): Expressing a position or commitment. Ex: "We will continue our dedication to innovation." The paper shows this is the AI's default, safe-zone function.
- Criticism (CRT): Attacking an opponent or a competitor's idea. Ex: "The failure of our competitor's approach is evident." Real politicians use this frequently; AI almost entirely avoids it.
- Self-Praise (SPR) & Praise of Others (OPR): Highlighting achievements.
Is your AI-generated content falling into these predictable traps? Let's analyze your brand voice.
Book a Free ConsultationKey Findings Reimagined: The AI Communication "Tell"
The paper's data reveals a clear divergence between human and AI communication patterns. These differences aren't just academic; they have profound implications for brand authenticity and persuasive impact.
Finding 1: AI Is "Chattier" and More Persuasive... Superficially
ChatGPT-4
Politicians
Enterprise Insight: The research, visualized above, shows that ChatGPT-4 used persuasive presuppositions (PMPs) more frequently per 1,000 words than the human politicians it mimicked. While this might seem like a positive, it often translates to a style that feels overly eager, formulaic, or inauthentic to a discerning audience. It's the difference between a seasoned salesperson and an over-rehearsed telemarketer. A custom AI can be tuned for the appropriate frequency, ensuring your message is potent, not pushy.
Finding 2: AI and Humans Use Different Linguistic Tools
Change-of-State Verbs (CSV)
Definite Descriptions (DEF)
Enterprise Insight: The data is stark. In the total corpus, ChatGPT relied heavily on Change-of-State Verbs (e.g., "start," "continue," "build"), while politicians more frequently used Definite Descriptions (e.g., "the crisis," "your problem"). This reveals AI's preference for action-oriented, forward-looking language, which is often a default "safe" template. Human experts, however, use definite descriptions to frame the narrative and establish context assertively. Your brand needs the flexibility to do both, a capability that requires custom model tuning.
Finding 3: The "Guardrail" Effect - AI Avoids Confrontation
Stance-Taking (STK)
Criticism (CRT)
Enterprise Insight: This is perhaps the most critical finding for businesses. ChatGPT's output was overwhelmingly dominated by non-confrontational Stance-Taking. It systematically avoided Criticism. This is a built-in safety featurea "guardrail"to prevent the AI from generating harmful or adversarial content. However, in a business context, this is a major limitation. Competitive analysis, sales battle cards, legal arguments, and persuasive marketing often require a degree of implicit or explicit criticism. Off-the-shelf AI simply cannot perform these strategic tasks effectively.
The Underlying Logic: AI's Predictable Associations
The research went a step further, revealing a strong statistical link between the *tools* AI uses and the *purpose* it aims for. This uncovers the model's simplistic, template-driven "thinking."
Unlocking AI's Core Logic: The Trigger-Function Link
Form
Criticism
Praise Others
Self-Praise
Stance-Taking
Change-of-State Verbs (CSV)
Definite Descriptions (DEF)
Enterprise Insight: This chart (a simplified model of the paper's Chi-square analysis) shows the AI's rigid rules. Boxes rising above the midline show a positive association (happens more than expected); boxes sinking below show a negative one. The AI has learned a strong, simple rule: Use Change-of-State Verbs (CSV) for Stance-Taking (STK). Conversely, it associates Definite Descriptions (DEF) with Criticism (CRT) and therefore avoids them. This is a predictable, robotic pattern. A custom solution from OwnYourAI.com breaks these rigid rules, teaching the model to use any linguistic tool for any strategic function, creating a truly flexible and powerful communication engine.
The OwnYourAI.com Solution: From Generic to Genius
Understanding these limitations is the first step. Overcoming them is where we provide value. Our methodology directly addresses the shortcomings revealed in the research, transforming a generic LLM into a bespoke asset that embodies your unique brand voice.
Calculate Your "Authenticity ROI"
Moving beyond generic AI isn't just about better-sounding text; it's about measurable business impact. A more authentic, strategically nuanced brand voice can lead to higher engagement, better conversion rates, and stronger brand loyalty. Use our calculator to estimate the potential value of a custom-tuned AI communication model.
Conclusion: Own Your AI, Own Your Voice
The "ChatGPT for President!" study serves as a crucial warning for the enterprise world. Relying on off-the-shelf AI is like giving every employee the same generic scriptit's functional, but it lacks the nuance, authenticity, and strategic edge needed to win in a competitive market. The paper proves that generic AI has a "tell"a predictable, non-confrontational, and formulaic style.
To truly leverage the power of AI, you must move beyond these limitations. By curating your own data, fine-tuning a model on your unique brand voice, and customizing its strategic capabilities, you can create a communication asset that is not only efficient but also powerfully effective. Don't let your brand sound like a default setting.
Ready to build an AI that speaks your language?
Schedule a Custom AI Strategy SessionReady to Get Started?
Book Your Free Consultation.
Let's Discuss Your AI Strategy!
Lets Discuss Your Needs
Select a Date
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat