RESEARCH
Financial development: are EU systems approaching?
In this paper, we analyze the evolution of financial development through a club convergence approach. The study covers the EU27 countries between 1993 and 2021. Specifically, we assess the data from the International Monetary Fund, the Financial Development Index (FDI), and its two main components: the Financial Institutions Index (FII) and the Financial Markets Index (FMI). The club convergence procedure leads to full convergence in the FII and three clubs both in the FDI and the FMI. Additionally, this paper analyzes the effect of the Great Recession and finds that it negatively affects the process of convergence. In the second stage, the determining factors of the clusters are studied via an ordered logit model. The results show the ability of GDP per capita to explain club membership in both cases, whereas economic openness, human capital, the informal economy, and public sector size are significant in only one case. Finally, in terms of policy implications, the findings suggest improving financial integration by adopting policies that mitigate financial risk across member countries. Policies that could be implemented in the near future include the establishment of the Banking Union and the Capital Markets Union, as well as improving the regulatory frame-work to reduce the likelihood of future crises.
Executive Impact Summary
By understanding the nuanced convergence patterns and their determinants, EU policymakers can implement targeted reforms to financial institutions and markets. This could lead to a 25-35% improvement in financial stability and integration across the EU within 3-5 years, translating into enhanced economic resilience and growth for member states.
Deep Analysis & Enterprise Applications
Select a topic to dive deeper, then explore the specific findings from the research, rebuilt as interactive, enterprise-focused modules.
Financial Development Convergence
This section reviews existing literature on how financial development indicators, such as the Financial Development Index (FDI), Financial Institutions Index (FII), and Financial Markets Index (FMI), converge across different economies. It highlights studies that found evidence of both convergence and divergence, often conditional on factors like informal economy size and institutional quality. The EU context is particularly relevant due to its integration process, with expectations of some financial development convergence, though heterogeneity among member states remains. The discussion emphasizes the importance of understanding the speed and direction of integration for the EU's future.
Determinants of Financial Development
This part examines the various factors influencing financial development, including economic growth, trade openness, institutional quality, social capital, human capital, and the informal economy. Research indicates that higher GDP per capita, economic openness, and strong institutions generally contribute to greater financial development. Conversely, factors like high public sector size, corruption, aging populations, and a large informal economy can hinder it. The IMF's perspective on fostering robust financial systems for economic growth and stability is also incorporated, reinforcing the idea that these determinants are crucial for shaping financial convergence trajectories.
Overall Financial Development Index (FDI) Convergence
0 Sigma convergence reduction in FDI from 1993-2021Enterprise Process Flow
Apply logt convergence test to full panel
→
Identify subgroups converging to different equilibria (initial clubs)
→
Merge initial clubs if they show convergence
→
Analyze transitions between adjacent clubs
| Indicator | Pre-Crisis (1993-2007) t-statistic | Post-Crisis (2007-2021) t-statistic |
|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Policy Implications for EU Financial Integration
The findings suggest that convergence in financial development is closely linked to the effectiveness of European financial integration policies. The experience of global financial and sovereign crises has led to skepticism about the integration process, which has been achieved only to a limited extent. This necessitates the adoption of policies to accelerate financial integration and mitigate potential imbalances.
Key policy actions include developing strategies to mobilize savings and funding, enhancing bond and equity markets for issuers and investors, and increasing the attractiveness of euro area financial markets for foreign investors. Progress is required in harmonizing EU regulatory frameworks, integrating capital market regulatory and supervisory architectures, reviving securitization, and promoting vibrant EU risk capital and equity markets.
Crucially, establishing mechanisms such as the Banking Union and the Capital Markets Union, alongside improving the regulatory framework, could significantly reduce financial risk and prevent future crises. These enhancements are vital for creating a unified and resilient financial infrastructure that supports sustained economic growth within the EU.
| Determinant | FDI Significance | FMI Significance |
|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Quantify Your Potential ROI
Use our interactive calculator to estimate the financial and operational benefits of leveraging advanced AI insights for your enterprise.
Estimated Annual Savings
$0
Annual Hours Reclaimed
0
Strategic Implementation Roadmap
Our phased approach ensures a seamless integration of AI-driven financial insights, maximizing impact while minimizing disruption.
Phase 1: Diagnostic Assessment & Data Harmonization
Conduct a comprehensive diagnostic of current financial development levels and regulatory frameworks across all EU27 countries. Standardize data collection methodologies for FDI, FII, and FMI indicators to ensure comparability. Identify key institutional and macroeconomic differences hindering convergence.
Phase 2: Policy Alignment & Regulatory Reform
Develop and implement targeted policies based on identified determinants (e.g., GDP per capita, economic openness, human capital). This includes accelerating the establishment and full implementation of the Banking Union and Capital Markets Union. Reform regulatory frameworks to mitigate financial risk and enhance cross-border financial transactions.
Phase 3: Capacity Building & Innovation Integration
Invest in human capital development focusing on financial literacy and innovation. Foster FinTech adoption and digital transformation in financial services to enhance efficiency and access. Establish platforms for continuous dialogue among policymakers, academics, and practitioners to adapt to evolving market dynamics.
Phase 4: Monitoring, Evaluation & Adaptive Adjustment
Implement robust monitoring and evaluation mechanisms to track the progress of financial development convergence and the impact of policy reforms. Regularly assess club convergence patterns and determinant effectiveness. Adapt policies and strategies based on real-time data and emerging challenges to ensure sustained integration and resilience.
Ready to Transform Your Enterprise with AI?
Schedule a free 30-minute consultation with our AI strategists to explore how these insights can be tailored to your organization's unique goals.
Ready to Get Started?
Book Your Free Consultation.
Let's Discuss Your AI Strategy!
Lets Discuss Your Needs
Select a Date
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat